top of page

Why State Is Strategy

Writer: Nick Jankel
Nick Jankel
6 hours ago
6 min read

How bodily and emotional states shape strategic decisions under pressure

In a steady, simple, predictable, and clear environment, leaders can rely on established routines, make quick calls, and protect what is working. In a VUCA++ world, where conditions can change while you are still deciding what to do, the ability to shift your bodily and emotional state becomes strategic. Your state shapes what feels urgent, whose input you can hear, and which possibilities you can imagine. By the time a leadership team chooses a strategy, its state has already shaped the choices on the table.

The four responses to VUCA++

Fast-changing, disrupted environments call for meaningful change, adaptation, transformation, and innovation. These are four ways of looking at the same underlying work of responding to a world that has changed. Meaningful change asks what people need to do differently. Adaptation asks what needs to adjust as conditions shift. Transformation asks what deeper patterns or assumptions have to change. Innovation asks what new way of creating value is now possible. A single strategic decision can involve all four.

The state that helps us defend what works can make it harder to see what needs to change. When the pressure rises, leaders need to be able to shift into a state where they can stay curious, take in unfamiliar perspectives, and work with others to find a response they couldn't see before.

What an executive team lost when the room changed state

I watched an executive team change state like dominoes.

We were about six months into a healthcare ecosystem innovation program led by Switch On Leadership for a leading life sciences business. We were in Silicon Valley for a two-day workshop when the head of the business unit walked in. He had the authority of a CEO in that room. He had been invited into the program but hadn't taken part until then, and he arrived without a briefing.

I'd worked hard to liberate this executive team from their usual routines, and to build trust in me, in the process, and in Switch On Leadership. These were SVPs, EVPs, and C-level leaders. One by one, I saw them shift into fear, into anxiety, into worrying what he thought of them. The workshop unraveled. So did the program and the pipeline of innovations we had begun to build. The team never got back to those transformational challenges.

Healthcare ecosystem innovation is one of the hardest areas in the world to innovate into. There are insurers, payers, patients, healthcare practitioners, legislation, vested interests, old habits, and ideologies. Each has a bearing on what can change, and people working in different parts of the system can see very different problems.

Senior leaders are trained to see a problem they can already solve and to solve it as quickly as possible. That training is useful when the problem is technical and the available solution is sound. Technical problems lead to incremental improvements. Transformational challenges lead to breakthrough innovations. Getting to a transformational challenge requires leaders to pause long enough to question how they have defined the problem in the first place.

We had done much of that work. This workshop was about finding the insights that could unlock breakthroughs once the problems had been defined properly. In a hierarchical organization, it had taken time to get the room warm enough for executives to challenge the assumptions they normally worked within.

The state of anxiety and urgency triggered premature closure. Open, creative, curious, collaborative thinking shut down. Back into silos. Back into power plays. Back into presenting, performing for the CEO. The difficult task of strategic innovation fell away just as we were beginning to see what might unlock it.

That is how state becomes strategy. The healthcare challenge was still there. What changed was the team's capacity to work on it. Once people were protecting their positions, it became harder to question the brief, hear a perspective from another part of the system, or explore an idea they couldn't yet defend. The team lost the conditions it needed to pursue a breakthrough.

How bodily signals become strategic decisions

Under pressure, leaders can feel an urge to move faster, end debate, or resolve tension. As McKinsey puts it in How Leaders Can Help Their Organizations Metabolize Strain, “That urgency is often the first signal that the body has gone on high alert.” In that workshop, I saw what can happen when an entire team picks up that signal at once.

You might notice a clenched jaw, a tight chest, or shallower breathing. The same shift can show up in the room as impatience with a colleague, confidence in the first workable answer, or a sudden desire to settle a question that is still open. A leader who ends the conversation at that moment changes the information the team gets to consider. When others take their cue from that leader, the team can leave with a decision that reflects what felt safest to say under pressure.

The business was later acquired and ceased to exist as a standalone company. I think about that when executives tell me they have no time to explore a transformational challenge. The need to act was real. So was the urge to get out of an uncomfortable conversation. A leadership team under pressure needs to ask which of those is setting its pace.

What are F-States and C-States in leadership?

In my Bio-Transformation work (BTX®), I use F-States and C-States as shorthand for recognizing how we are responding under pressure. “The F-States are signals that people are in Control & Protect Mode. The C-States are signals that people are in Create & Connect Mode.”

Fight, flight, and freeze are familiar. Some of the more subtle F-States can look like competence in a leadership meeting:

  • Fix: “rushing to ‘solve’ everything and to disappear problems, to make the discomfort go away, often by over-functioning for others.”

  • Fixate: “obsessing over one issue, one person, or one competitor and trying to enrol others in that fixation too.”

  • Figure: “over-analyzing, intellectualizing, and trying to think our way out of threat or discomfort, rather than feeling it or engaging with it.”

Control & Protect Mode can serve us well when conditions are steady and a proven response fits. It can also help contain an immediate threat. Its limits become clear when the situation keeps changing and we're still learning what the problem is. Rushing to fix a failing workflow can close off the very conversation that would tell us why it keeps failing.

C-States include curiosity, “where open-minded exploration replaces judgment or fear,” and collaboration, “where genuine partnership and co-creation become possible.” The team still has to make a decision. Its members now have a better chance of hearing something that changes the decision.

How an executive team can shift state before making a decision

Before the most senior person in the room offers a view on an unresolved challenge, start with a question from my keynote slides. Then ask whose perspective is missing and what the team could learn before it commits.

  1. What does premature closure look like here? Am I rushing to fix this, asking for more analysis to defer a difficult call, or staying quiet because challenging the plan feels costly?

  2. What are we missing? Ask someone closest to the work to describe a specific case that challenges the team's current definition of the problem. Hear the example before debating solutions.

  3. What could we learn before we commit? Agree on one question a bounded test can answer, name an owner, and decide when the team will review the evidence.

These are questions for a real decision. The pause earns its place if it helps the team hear a missing signal, reconsider a plausible assumption, or choose a better next move.

What this means for leaders facing disruption

As a leadership keynote speaker and AI keynote speaker, I work with audiences facing decisions about meaningful change, adaptation, transformation, and innovation. One AI rollout can call for all four. Leaders may need to change what people do each day, adapt the rollout when new evidence comes in, rethink who makes decisions across the organization, and explore new ways to serve customers. Their state helps determine how much of that work they can see and take on under pressure.

For practical ways to build that capacity, see Five Tools to Adapt at the Speed of AI. For more on how pressure shapes what leaders see, read The Intelligence Paradox.

Frequently asked questions

Is an F-State always a problem?

F-States can help us protect ourselves and respond to urgent risks. They become a problem when a protective response keeps a team from seeing what has changed, listening to new information, or considering a different course.

What does a C-State look like in an executive meeting?

It can look like a leader asking a sincere question about an idea they disagree with, a team hearing a concern without punishing the person who raised it, or executives designing a limited experiment together when the evidence is incomplete.

What does “state is strategy” mean for a CEO?

It means the CEO's state influences the evidence, dissent, and ideas that enter the decision. In a fast-changing environment, making room for a challenge to the prevailing view can bring a strategic option into play that would otherwise go unheard.

At your next leadership meeting, choose one decision that keeps coming back to the table. Notice what happens in the room when it comes up. Ask what the team might see or hear if it could stay curious about that decision for a little longer.

If your leadership team is navigating AI disruption, uncertainty, or a transformation that demands more adaptability, explore my leadership keynotes and keynotes on leading through change. To see how audiences can put these ideas into practice during an event, explore the keynote formats.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page